by the Price Earnings Ratio Stock Value Tracker Team

Check out the PE Tracker here.

The recent volatility in the stock market is a rude reminder that different types of stocks – oil stocks, utilities, foreign ADRs, etc. – can see different kinds of performance.

This is an opportune time to reflect on a very profitable trade I made in 2017, using price earnings ratios as my guide to trade different types of stocks. I looked at two industries. The financial industry which includes banks and the “real economy,” which by my definition includes goods producers like Walmart and excludes finance and tech companies.


My hypothesis was that the P/E ratio of stocks in the financial industry would converge to the real economy P/E ratio after noticing a big disparity between these two numbers. Let’s say the P/Es were 10 and 20, respectively. Academic theory and popular trading strategies like “Dogs of the Dow” hold that P/E ratios of different stocks should converge to the same number (revert to the mean) in the long run. (If you want recent evidence from an academic, a paper by Kevin Klassen here confirmed mean reversion in P/E ratios from 2008-2017.) I expected the sentiment around the new presidential administration and its actions to act as a catalyst for my trade in the short-term.


I bought a trading instrument to reflect a basket of financial stocks in March 2017. You can take the financial index from Vanguard (Ticker: VFH) as a close substitute. I set a P/E ratio target for the financial index. This involved a little bit of magic and a little bit of judgement based on facts I won’t get into here. The P/E target was not quite as high as the level of the P/E of the real economy stocks, but higher than what I believed to be a depressed current P/E ratio for financial stocks. Let’s say the target was 15.

I closed the trade almost a year later by selling the financial index in Feb 2018 once the P/E ratio hit my target.

How did my purchase fare?

The P/E ratio of financial stocks indeed went higher and converged closer to the level of real economy stocks! More concretely, financials were up 18% in price vs. the S&P 500 increase of 16% over the mentioned time frame. This is not counting dividends which are higher for financials.

What’s more, if you exclude financial and tech companies from the S&P 500 to include only “real economy” stocks, the outperformance of financials was even more profound. My hypothesis proved correct.


Here is another way to look at this concept. Compare two stocks, one from the financial world and one from the real economy world. If you had bought both in 2015, your Bank of America stock (PE Ratio: 7.2x) would have over the course of this period typically outperformed Johnson & Johnson (PE Ratio: 23x). Notice the 2016 presidential election result was a huge catalyst that sent Bank of America’s stock price sharply up. Now if you had chosen Goldman Sachs, which has been experiencing company specific issues, the story would be much different. That is why I recommend looking at baskets or indexes of stocks to diversify away company-specific issues. And, of course, the recent market crash related to the coronavirus definitely adds a large element of uncertainty om the near term.

I believe that with an understanding of P/E ratios and good timing, you can continue to make money by betting on P/E ratio convergence. I believe it so much that I created an app with my team to serve as a handy dashboard for traders and investors. With my Price Earnings Stock Value Tracker app, you can see the P/E ratios of 18 critical US companies plus the median of three custom indexes, which include financial and real economy stocks.

Check out the PE Tracker here


Updated September 13, 2020

At WallStreetSurvivor, we subscribe to dozens stock recommendation and advisory newsletters. There is ONE newsletter that is constantly outperforming all of the others--The Motley Fool Stock Advisor.

ONE of this year's Motley Fool Stock Picks Has Already quadrupled, ONE has tripled, and another TWO Have Already Doubled in just 8 months of of 2020!

We have been tracking ALL of the Motley Fool stock picks since January 2016. That's almost 5 years, 55 months and 110 stock picks. As of Friday, September 11, 2020 the Motley Fool's January 2 stock pick (TSLA) is up 333%, their March 19th pick (ZM) is up 209% in just 6 months, and another two have more than doubled. In addition, 6 of their 2019, 8 of their 2018, 8 of their 2016, 9 of theire 2017 and 13 of their 2016 picks have also doubled. Most impressively, over the last 5 years that we have been tracking every recommendation, their average stock pick is up 135%. That beats the SP500 by an average of 95%. And that's even accounting for all of this COVID mess that has wreaked havoc on most stocks. BUT, the Fool has done so well because they have quickly identified stocks this year that will perform well in the post-COVID world. THAT is how the Fool consistently does so well--they adapt and constantly pick stocks before everyone else realizes the opportunities.

  • CrowdStrike (CRWD) -- June 4, 2020 pick is already up 32%
  • Shopify (SHOP) – April 2, 2020 pick and it is already up 164%
  • Zoom Video (ZM) – March 19, 2020 pick and it is already up 209%
  • DexCom (DXCM) picked Feb 20, 2020 right before the market crashed and it is still up 41%
  • Tesla (TSLA) picked January 2, 2020 before the crash and it is up 333%
  • HubSpot (HUBS) picked December 5, 2019 and it is up 82%
  • Netflix (NFLX) picked November 21, 2019 and it is up 54%
  • Trade Desk (TTD) picked November 11, 2019 and up 117%
  • Zoom Video originally picked Oct 3 and it is up 398%
  • SolarEdge (SEDG) picked September 19, 2019 and it is up 105%

Now no one can guarantee that their next picks will be as strong, but our 5 years of experience has been super-profitable. They also claim that since inception, their average pick is up 529% and now we believe them. You sure don’t want to risk missing out. Many analysts are saying that we have passed the bottom of this COVID crisis and stocks will recover quickly. So make sure you have the best stocks in your portfolio.

Normally the Fool service is priced at $199 per year but they are currently offering it for a NEW SUBSCRIBER DISCOUNT of just $99/year if you click this link

CLICK HERE to get access to all The Motley Fool’s Stock Picks and their next 12 months of picks for just $99 per Year! 



Robinhood was the first brokerage site to NOT charge commissions when they opened in 2013. They just past 10,000,000 accounts and to celebrate they are offering up to $1,000 in free stock when you open a new account.

Here’s the details: You must click on a special promo link to open your new Robinhood account. Then when you fund your account with at least $10, you will receive one stock valued between $5 and $500. Then, you will get a link to share with your friends. Every time one of your friends opens an account, you will receive another free stock valued between $5 and $500. Click here to learn more about this Special Robinhood offer.

Claim your free stock NOW (before it’s too late)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *