Should Trump Take Credit For Stock Market Record Gains

Since November 8, Election Day, the US stock market has gained nearly 4 trillion dollars in market value.

To hear the President tell it, the entire rise should be attributed to his actions, but just how much has the stock market gone up? And is the President responsible for the increase in the stock market?

According to Time magazine, in Trump’s first 100 days the S&P 500 gained 5.5%. That’s a very decent performance, even when pitted against the first 100 days in office of other presidents. When you crunch the numbers, it turns out Trump comes in fifth place, with George H.W. Bush and Barack Obama right above him. From January 20th, 2017 to Oct 20, 2017, the S&P 500 has returned about 15%. That is very impressive. The previous president saw a nearly 38% increase in the same time period, but 15% is nothing to sneeze at either.

How much of this should we attribute to the president?

Trump has yet to truly fulfill any of his promises regarding infrastructure and tax cuts. These promises were said to be driving the stock market surge post-election. It’s not out of this world to believe that the confidence gained from these promises drove prices up. Stock markets rise and fall with consumer sentiment so why not here?

The stock market has also, historically, moved along with the four-year presidential election cycle. In the first year of a president’s first term, the market tends to move up, at an average return of 8.2% (1900-2015). Since World War II, the average return in the first year of a US president’s inaugural term is a little lower, at 6.2%.

Another thing to keep in mind is that elections are often decided by how the economy is doing. If the country is doing well, Americans will tend to keep the incumbent in office for a second term. If the economy is hitting a road bump, then Americans tend to ask for change. According to Forbes, more than 80% of the time, the incumbent party wins when markets are climbing in the months leading up to the election. For reference see Barack Obama’s victory in 2008, taking office after George Bush and a turbulent stock market leading up to the election.

It is true that the incumbent party lost this time around, with the markets flat to declining in the lead up to the election. So where does that leave us?

Here’s what we do know. Elections and stock markets can be influenced by human emotion and some element of herding behavior. The euphoria around a presidential election seems to drive stock markets up, as the data show. It would seem Trump’s case is no different, even if his stock market bump outperforms the average. It does help him that he takes office on the back of a multi-year stock market bull run. He has momentum working in his favor.

The other thing we do know is that the health of the actual economy matters. If policy is enacted that can affect the economy, then the stock market will follow. If no policy specifically targeting the economy is put in place then Trump is merely taking credit for market forces that would create stock market surges, surges which would happen with or without him.

What has Trump done for the economy?

The truth is, with Trump, very little policy has been enacted.

According to CNN, Trump signed 53 bills into law between his inauguration and the end of August 2017. “In all, two of the laws has created a new policy, 15 have rolled back rules and regulations issued under Obama’s administration, 10 had to do with designating something or working to create a new initiative, 11 changed or expanded existing legislation, and 15 were related to government funding or operations.”

The Obamacare repeal is currently struggling to get through, and the infrastructure and tax reform bills seem to be going nowhere fast. Alan Blinder, professor of Economics at Princeton, says that “in terms of Economic policy Trump has basically done nothing besides cutting back regulations in a minor way.”  The other thing to keep in mind is that economic policy is the type of thing that can cause stock market surges due to anticipation at first, but the real benefits take years and maybe even decades to realize.

On the face of things, everything looks rosy. Jobs growth has increased under Trump’s reign. Unemployment has continued to go down, and the stock market bull run continues unabated. These are all good signs, but how much of it has roots that stretch back to policies and reforms enacted under Obama in response to the Great Recession in 2008? With a stock market run-up that has lasted nearly a decade, the second-longest on record, how much longer does this bull market have to run? Is it simply running on fumes, fumes that Trump is happy to take credit for?

When it comes to examining history, there are two competing views. One of the Great Man Theory, where the course of history is explained by the impact that great men have had through their individual influence. Winston Churchill, Alexander the Great, etc.

The other view is that history is really a result of macro-trends and social forces that culminate in the events that we then study afterward.

In the sense that any and every president has an effect on the stock market through market forces bigger than he, then yes, Trump can claim responsibility for stock market gains. But so could any president. However, it’s not as sexy when you couch it in those terms, is it?

January 2, 2021 Update: We have just announced our BEST STOCK NEWSLETTER of 2020 AWARD!

CLICK HERE to find out which stock newsletter was up 78% in 2020 (and whose 2019 picks are now up 113%).

*** Our Award for BEST STOCK NEWSLETTER of 2020 ALERT ***

Updated January 2, 2021

At WallStreetSurvivor, we subscribe to dozens stock recommendation and advisory newsletters. There is ONE newsletter that is constantly outperforming all of the others--The Motley Fool Stock Advisor.

Five of their 2020 stock picks have doubled and the average return of all 24 of their stock picks for 2020 is up 78%!

We have been tracking ALL of the Motley Fool stock picks since January 2016. That's 5 years and 120 stock picks. As of Friday, January 1, 2021 the Motley Fool's January stock pick (TSLA) is up 720%, their March pick (ZM) is up 172%, their April pick of SHOP is up 226% and their June pick CRWD is up 120%; and another two have more than doubled. In addition, 10 of their 2019, 12 of their 2018, 11 of their 2017, 15 of their 2016. Most impressively, over the last 5 years that we have been tracking every recommendation, their average stock pick is up 209%--tht means over the last 5 years their stock picks, on average, have TRIPLED!

Now no one can guarantee that their next picks will be as strong, but our 5 years of experience has been super-profitable. The important thing about the Fool stock picks is you have to buy them the day they are recommended because they usually pop 5-10% in the first 72 hours after the release their recommendation. You sure don’t want to risk missing out on their next pick.

Normally the Fool service is priced at $199 per year but they are currently offering a NEW SUBSCRIBER DISCOUNT that allows you to get theiir next 24 stock picks for just $99/year. HERE is the LINK to visit their New Subscriber Discount page.

CLICK HERE to get access to all The Motley Fool’s Stock Picks and their next 12 months of picks for just $99 per Year! 



GET UP TO $1,000 IN FREE STOCK

WHEN YOU OPEN A ROBINHOOD BROKERAGE ACCOUNT

Robinhood was the first brokerage site to NOT charge commissions when they opened in 2013. They just past 10,000,000 accounts and to celebrate they are offering up to $1,000 in free stock when you open a new account.

Here’s the details: You must click on a special promo link to open your new Robinhood account. Then when you fund your account with at least $10, you will receive one stock valued between $5 and $500. Then, you will get a link to share with your friends. Every time one of your friends opens an account, you will receive another free stock valued between $5 and $500. Click here to learn more about this Special Robinhood offer.

Claim your free stock NOW (before it’s too late)



Comments are closed.