Ah, Black Friday. That fateful day every year when American consumers rush to retail stores everywhere to battle it out for the ultimate holiday savings. And for investors, the market usually responds. Because it’s such a historically good shopping day, investors often use it as a barometer for the success of the holiday shopping season as a whole.

ALSO READ: The January Effect

Views of Early Black Friday Shopping at a Best Buy Store

So how did this year’s Black Friday go? Well, you may have noticed that the market was down on Monday…which tells us the shopping bonanza wasn’t quite as bonanza-y as investors were hoping. In fact, the National Retail Federation reported that sales were down 11% from 2013.

So why did Black Friday sales go down?

Extended Discount Windows

One explanation for the less than stellar sales could be the fact that retailers have been extending the time period for their discounts. According to Adweek:

“Retailers—both in stores and online—made deep discounts in the days and weeks leading up to the holiday, rather than saving them all for one day.”

If shoppers have reason to believe that the Black Friday sales aren’t unique, or that they will continue to see low prices throughout December, there is little incentive for them to battle the crowds on Black Friday.


This could be good news for investors, because a lackluster Black Friday doesn’t exactly mean a lackluster holiday season as a whole. In fact, the CEO of the National Retail Federation himself expects the holiday season in aggregate to grow 4% over 2013, saying that earlier discount offers were simply moving purchases from Black Friday to earlier in the month.

Shoppers Moving Online

Of course, the easiest way to avoid those abusive holiday crowds is to shop from the comfort of your very own home. Indeed, more people did their holiday shopping via “click” in 2014 than ever before. IBM reports that online shopping traffic on Thanksgiving Day grew 13% from last year. Good news for investors who have online retailers in their portfolio.

Another interesting highlight from IBM’s data is that, for the first time, more online traffic was coming from mobile devices than from PC’s.

“Thanksgiving Day mobile traffic accounted for 52.1 percent of all online traffic – the first time mobile devices have outpaced their PC counterparts for online browsing.”

So it looks like shoppers aren’t only too lazy to actually leave their house to go shopping, they’re also too lazy to boot up their computer! Although with the enormous capabilities of tablets and smartphones these days, who can blame them?

Of course, it wasn’t all bad. Some companies were able to exceed expectations this Black Friday, despite overall sales going down.

Black Friday Winners:


Because online shopping increased so much this year, it’s no surprise that the country’s largest online retailer saw a lot of that traffic. Marketwatch reports that Amazon’s sales rose 24% on Black Friday, and a whopping 46% on Saturday, both metrics far exceeding the industry average.

Best Buy

Apparently the items shoppers are willing to leave their house to buy are electronics. CNBC reported that their sales were up 16% over last year. But that isn’t to say that all of Best Buy’s traffic was on foot; they saw so much online traffic that BestBuy.com crashed due to overwhelming demand!


Two of the top three selling items on Black Friday were gaming consoles, so naturally GameStop came out a winner for sales. Lines were seen around the country for GameStop’s now traditional midnight opening, and shoppers were treated to bundled offerings of the Playstation 4 and Xbox One, as well as discounted pre-owned games.

Deep Discounters

Kohl’s and Family Dollar, two chains known for their extreme discounts, both had better than expected sales, indicating that despite the recent pick up in the economy, consumers may not yet feel comfortable splurging on holiday gifts.

Not the End of the World

The market’s negative reaction on Monday (both the Nasdaq and S&P 500 were down roughly 1%) would indicate that investors do correlate Black Friday numbers with the overall success of the holiday season for retailers… but should they?

US News and World Report doesn’t think so; this chart shows that Black Friday sales and overall holiday sales don’t always have the same patterns. In a tough economy, for example, shoppers might lean on Black Friday more because they need the discounts. Whereas a good economy might lead to more shopping throughout December, but not necessarily on the day of the biggest sale.

Furthermore, great Black Friday numbers aren’t always positive indicators for a company’s health. Sure, sales volumes are going up, but what role do deep discounts play in profit margins? This very concern is attributed to Best Buy’s drop in stock price on Monday. Yes, you read that right, despite being a “winner” in Black Friday sales numbers, BBY went down 5% when the market opened. A good reminder that sales volumes are nice, but might not always tell the whole story.

What do you all think? Are you Black Friday believers? Or is the holiday shopping environment changing enough that it doesn’t matter so much anymore?

Wall Street Survivor Courses

Important Reminder!

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor ranks as our #1 Best Investment Newsletter for the third year in a row.

Their stock recommendations continue to beat all of the other newsletters and they maintain a very high accuracy of their picks. Their 24 stock picks from 2018 have outperformed the market by an average of 44% as of July 7, 2019. Read that again. I didn’t say their stock picks are up an average of 44%, I said they have BEAT THE MARKET by 44%.

No other newsletter comes close to that. You may have seen the Motley Fool’ advertisements that their picks are up 367% compared to the market’s 80%. Is The Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor really as good as they claim?

Our results, at least since January 2016, suggest YES. You can now get their latest stock picks for ONLY $19/month or $99/year. But this is a special limited time offer. It expires tonight at midnight.

Get the Motley Fool's Latest picks

P.s. this offer is still backed by their 30-day guarantee

Previous articleThe January Effect
Next articleThe End of the Commodity Supercycle